Compare dependency graphs
Put two dependency graphs next to each other and read what the second one states differently from the first: the axioms it adds, removes or relates another way, and the default rules it adds, drops or changes, each with its legal basis, its status and a plain explanation. Nothing shown here is legal advice.
DALICC deontic dependency graph, version 2, against Brazil default rules, version 2.
Axioms: 0 added, 0 removed, 0 changed. Default rules: 3 added, 0 removed, 0 changed.
What the second graph adds
Default rules 3
| Status | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
dalicc:moralRightsRestriction
Moral rights restriction
|
Not waivable | Brazil | Lei 9.610/1998 article 27: the moral rights of the author are inalienable and cannot be renounced, so a clause of the licence that gives them up has no effect | Proposed |
| What this rule does: This rule adds nothing to a licence that says nothing about moral rights; it reports a finding when a licence permits the licensee to set them aside. Brazilian copyright law declares the moral rights of the author inalienable and impossible to renounce, so a clause that gives them up has no effect. A person combining licences under this graph sees the finding beside a licence that claims such a waiver. | ||||
dalicc:reverseEngineerForInteroperability
Reverse engineer for interoperability
|
Granted by default | Brazil | Lei 9.609/1998 article 6(IV): the integration of a program, keeping its essential characteristics, into an application or operating system, where that is technically indispensable to the user's needs and for the exclusive use of whoever carried it out, is not an infringement. The law has no exception for decompiling or reverse engineering | Proposed |
| What this rule does: A licence that says nothing about reverse engineering for interoperability is read as allowing the narrower act the Brazilian software law permits. That law allows a user to integrate a program into an application or operating system, keeping its essential characteristics, where that is technically indispensable to the user's needs and for the user's exclusive use. It does not provide an exception for decompiling or reverse engineering, so this rule is only an approximation of the action it is attached to. | ||||
dalicc:textAndDataMining
Text and data mining
|
Not granted by default | Brazil | Lei 9.610/1998 article 46 lists the limitations on copyright and names no general exception for text and data mining | Proposed |
| What this rule does: A licence that says nothing about text and data mining is read as not allowing it. The Brazilian copyright law lists the limitations on copyright and names no general exception for mining, so a mining act that reproduces a protected work needs a licence that grants it, unless a narrower limitation of article 46 applies to the facts. Combining a licence that is silent about it with one that permits it shows a conflict marked as coming from this rule. | ||||
What the second graph does not have
Nothing: every statement of DALICC deontic dependency graph is in Brazil default rules too.
What both have in a different form
Nothing: no statement is in both graphs in a different form.